Suga Pie Sweets & Treats
Carrot Cake
Carrot Cake
Couldn't load pickup availability
A spiced carrot cake cookie with a creamy cheesecake filling and a decorative chocolate carrot on top. All the cozy flavor of the classic, in cookie form.
Meet the Flavors
The "OG" Brown Butter Chocolate Chip
The one that started it all. Nutty brown butter, chunks of chocolate, crackly edges, flaky salt. Still our #1 seller.
The Dubai Experience
That viral pistachio chocolate bar, in cookie form. Crispy kataifi, pistachio cream, dark chocolate. If you've been curious — this is it.
The Biscoff Situation
Cookie butter melts out of the middle. A whole Biscoff cookie sits on top. Warm it for ten seconds and understand the name.
Cookie Monster
Om nom nom… this cookie means business.
Our signature brown butter cookie gets a Cookie Monster makeover, loaded with Oreo chunks, semi-sweet chocolate chunks, and creamy white chocolate chunks in every bite. Finished with those adorable edible Cookie Monster eyes on top because, obviously, he had to make an appearance.
Soft, gooey, chocolatey, crunchy, and completely irresistible.
One bite and you’ll understand why Cookie Monster would absolutely steal the whole box.
Teddy Graham Smores
Graham cracker crumbles and semi-sweet chocolate throughout, a Hershey's square and toasted marshmallow in the middle, Teddy Grahams standing guard on top. Campfire nostalgia, no fire required.
Faqs
When will my cookies ship?
Every cookie box is baked fresh to order and shipped on Mondays and Wednesdays.
Shipping Schedule
- Orders placed Wednesday–Sunday ship Monday.
- Orders placed Monday–Tuesday ship Wednesday.
You'll receive a tracking email as soon as your order is on its way.
What are the order cutoff times?
To ensure every box is baked fresh, we have shipping cutoffs.
Monday Shipping: Order by Sunday at 8:00 PM PT
Wednesday Shipping: Order by Tuesday at 8:00 PM PT
Orders placed after the cutoff will ship on the next scheduled shipping day.
How long do the cookies stay fresh?
Every cookie is individually heat sealed to lock in freshness.
• Best enjoyed within 5–7 days
• Freeze for up to 3 months
• Microwave for 10–15 seconds for a warm, bakery-fresh cookie.
Where do you ship?
We currently ship throughout California only.
Most orders arrive within 1–2 business days after shipping.
Please double-check your shipping address before placing your order, as we cannot reroute packages once they've shipped.